| |
New Calls to Permit Foreign Drug Distributors in Mexico
20 Mar 08
Julio Portales, Novartis's (Switzerland) vice-president of corporate affairs, has proposed a series of new measures to reduce the price of drugs in Mexico, including allowing foreign drug distributors to operate there.
Global Insight Perspective | | Significance | Swiss drug company Novartis has proposed a number of measures to reduce drug prices in Mexico, of which the most radical is allowing foreign distributors to operate on Mexican soil. | Implications | Novartis's proposals come in light of the imminent creation of a new co-ordinating commission that will negotiate the price of drugs on behalf of all public sector health institutions. Consequently, Mexico's drug industry is likely to be severely squeezed. | Outlook | Under the current terms of NAFTA, foreign distributors are not permitted to operate in Mexico. Realistically, therefore, it seems that the drug industry's best chance of making up losses lies in convincing the public sector to increase the volume of its purchases. |
According to Julio Portales, who was quoted in the Reforma newspaper, if Mexico is serious about lowering medicine prices it has to permit the entry of international distributors; increase the volume of purchases in the public sector in order to offer larger discounts in the private sector; and expand medical directories to include drugs that have shown themselves to have a good cost-to-benefit ratio. Drug Distributors Enjoy Healthy Margins A drug manufacturer bases the retail price displayed on a product's packaging on its average price in six reference countries (see Mexico: 28 September 2007: Mexican Finance Ministry Proposes New Pricing Model for Patented Medicines). However, drug companies then have to increase their prices by 23% in order for pharmacists to operate with a margin of 15% and distributors with a margin of 8%. Many manufacturers believe that the high margins for these two sectors have been inflating the price of medicines in Mexico. Manufacturers' concerns have been amplified by the imminent creation of the so-called Co-ordinating Commission for the Negotiation of Medicine Prices and Other Health Supplies, which will negotiate the price of drugs on behalf of all the public sector health institutions (see Mexico: 14 February 2008: Creation of Mexican Price Commission Imminent). The concern here is that the new commission will only affect manufacturers, and will not decentralise distribution or lower prices in the private market. According to Portales, if prices in the private market are to be lowered it needs to go hand-in-hand with increased purchases in the public sector. Outlook and Implications In the past, the relatively high price of drugs in Mexico has been variously attributed to the local manufacturing requirement, the 20-year patent protection period and to import costs. Although opening the market up to foreign distributors could indeed lead to lower prices, current legislation does not permit it. According to the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), only national companies can obtain permission to offer transport services between two points on Mexican territory. Currently, around 30 drug distributors exist in Mexico, although two of these, Casa Saba and Nadro, together account for 70% of the private market. Meanwhile, it has been estimated that the new price negotiation commission will create savings of approximately 5 billion pesos (US$464 million) on public sector purchases, which would leave a massive hole in the finances of Mexico's drug industry (see Mexico: 25 February 2008: Mexico's New Price Commission Predicted to Make Savings of US$464 mil.). In order to offset this, the association of research-based pharmaceutical companies, AMIIF, has been campaigning for the savings to be channelled towards additional purchases.
|
|
|